The period between 1986’s critically adored, Franchise-Palmer idolised, and commercially… tolerated… ‘Parade‘ album and 1987’s ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ exactly a year later might have been the most artistically insatiable yet commercially frustrating of Prince’s career. ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ wasn’t even His first album of 1987, as January had also seen the release of ‘8’, the debut album by the jazz fusion band Madhouse. A jazz fusion ‘band’ made up of *checks notes* Prince (plus Eric Leeds ocassionally on saxophone and flute). It’s… fine? I’m honestly out of my depth, I have no idea if it’s the greatest jazz fusion album ever or a boring piece of derivative trash. Unfortunately, no songs from ‘8’ make this top 40. Madhouse’s second and last album, ’16’, would be released later in 1987.
But the real struggles came from the music that Prince didn’t release. One album under a completely different pseudonym, a musical, an abandoned movie, an abandoned triple album with the Revolution, which was then changed into a completely different abandoned triple album once Prince felt He needed to dump all the stuff He’d done with The Revolution. Eventually the public got to hear arguably the greatest double album of all time because of the compromise that Prince made with Warner Brothers records. It was, essentially, the least amount of music that the record company could get Prince to record.
But that’s a tale for another time, as – while I cannot yet spoil whether I think much of this album – I can exclusively reveal that ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ has been ranked among the best 40 albums of 2026, so we’ll talk more about it in December. For now, it’s all about the music maaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaan.
There were roughly 80 something songs recorded in that 12 months. Proper, fully formed, fully composed, properly recorded songs – I wasn’t having to wade through 40 minute studio jams that some weirdo had decided to codename Squirrel Meat Funk, or whatever (with all due respect to 3 Nigs Watchin’ A Kung Fu Movie). And that 1st April 1986 (the day after the release of the Godly ‘Parade’ album) to 31st March 1987 (‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’) timeline is sometimes loosely applied. But, as always, it could not exist without the essential https://princevault.com. It’s quite a trip, and you’re gonna have a great time
Here’s the YouTube playlist, you lazy bastards.
First released on 2020‘s Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition – recorded 18th April 1986
I’ma build a big tall wall, baby
Stone circle so you can’t get out
Big tall wall, baby
True love is what it’s all about
Yeah, we’re starting a little problematically here tonight, folks.
Artistically, Prince breaking up the Revolution may have been the most significant event of 1986/87, but personally the biggest and most damaging change of that period (or almost any period of His life) may have been the end of His engagement and relationship with Susannah Melvoin, twin sister of Revolution guitarist Wendy. Susannah was Prince’s first proper girlfriend, the first He’d live with, and the first person He’d be engaged to marry. Many people who might know about it say that Susannah was the real love of His life. The proposed cover of ‘Dream Factory‘ – the originally planned Prince and the Revolution follow up to ‘Parade – would be a painting by Susannah, and much of the songs would be about Prince’s relationship with her.
Prince was also, however, a massive fucking pain to be in a relationship with. He was controlling, selfish, and occasionally mean. Any relationship Prince was in was only ever going to be of vaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaastly secondary importance to Him that His music. He’d expect any partner of His to be committed to Him to an almost insane degree, but to also be completely cool with Him shagging all the most beautiful women in the world. Also, He was recording 80+ songs every year and playing on stage every other night, how much time is there likely to be to spend together?? Three nights a year?? When your partner and bandmember are twins, you know a lot of your awful behaviour is being shared. Prince tried to solve this by getting rid of the band member in October 1986. Susannah decided that she should make things even easier, and left Prince a couple of months later.
Susannah apparently finds it difficult to listen to Big Tall Wall to this day, obviously finding that its tale of an obsessive lover imprisoning their partner in a castle as the best expression of true love hits a little too close to home (“Ooh pretty mama you can scream and shout, oh no!”).
Just after ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ was released, Prince would record a second version, far more musically interesting, but still bizarrely upbeat considering how dark the lyrics are.
39 There’s Something I Like About Being Your Fool
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition‘ (2020)- 25th January 1987
We’re going to get more songs from that Jill Jones debut album on this year’s list, which considering how many songs made the previous year’s countdown I simply have to assume is one of the greatest albums ever made. It’s obviously good enough for Jill Jones to even turn down this lovely, light, reggae infused song when it was first mooted in 1985 because she didn’t like the lyrics “Time after time, you spend all my money/Honey, I don’t mind when you wreck my car/You mess around all over town/But, honey, we’re still cool/’Cause there’s something I like about being your fool”). The song was eventually finalised in early 1987 and offered to Bonnie Raitt, who would also have a bit of an issue with the lyrics – “I appreciated the enthusiasm, but they were not in my key. The topics were not things I was comfortable singing”. We’re gonna get to some songs that didn’t make people feel uncomfortable soon, I promise.
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020) – 28th December 1986
OK, but not quite yet.
Check it out Wally, huh, I’m on the prowl tonight
‘Cause my baby don’t love me no more
She said, she said, “Well, maybe I do, just not like I did before”
This time it would be Prince Himself whose own lyrics made him incredibly uncomfortable. The original, almost mythical version of Wally was recorded soon after Susannah had left Prince and originally named Babyless (I’m already feeling uncomfortable). Engineer Susan Rodgers was there to witness how it had hit Prince (“I knew that he was in pain… It was pretty easy to tell, but Prince didn’t like to admit any weakness. … It’s a genuine emotion that he’s feeling, but he doesn’t want to advertise broadly to people that he’s feeling down“) and respond with the most nakedly emotional song He’d ever dared to record. “It’s beautiful, just beautiful. There’s a crescendo. The song gets huge. It breaks down. He says, ‘I’m not going out any more’. The background vocal arrangements, the expression of it was just gorgeous. Of course he played all the instruments”. Susan’s mind was blown, and she couldn’t wait for the world to hear this new, emotionally open side of Prince.
Prince, however, didn’t like the idea of showing so big a crack in this carefully orchestrated persona that He’d worked so hard to build. He immediately demanded that Susan wipe all 24 tracks so that the song could never be heard. Susan was obviously distraught, and pleaded with Prince to at least think about it for a day, she couldn’t imagine the world not being able to hear a song so beautiful. As Susan protested, Prince simply walked over to the console, pushed all the faders up to maximum, and pressed record, making the song unlistenable. The song has become legendary, but it’s also one which we will never hear.
What survives is the recording that Prince made the next day. It’s still great, don’t get me wrong, but now there’s a far bigger divide between the song and Prince Himself, with added layers of saxophone and trumpet and lyrics that don’t dive quite as deep (though we still have the eyebrow raising “Are you goin’ with that same dame?/You know, the one with the beautiful chest and the gorgeous mouth/’Cause if you are, I was wonderin’ if she had a sister”). Longtime Necessary Evil readers (the Real Ones) will also notice how it borrows some lyrics from 1983’s mind blowing 50 minute Billy (108th best song of 2023).
‘Wally’ is longtime bodyguard Wally Stafford, who Prince imagines addressing, and who at least had the grace to name his autobiography ‘Wally, Where’d You Get Those Glasses?‘.
37 It Be’s Like That Sometimes
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020)- 11th October 1986
Heeeeeeeeeeeeeeey! There’s no upsetting lore behind this song or any evidence of people being upset and/or disturbed by the lyrics! This is just a lovely little song!
Considering it was recorded in the days following The Revolution’s disbanding, there are certainly lyrics you could pore over if you so wished (“This is for those of you on your way up/Same motherfuckers that make you/Break you, when you had enough”; “Stay a rebel, oh/You owe us a brighter day/’Cause on your way down, you can laugh now/’Cause you did it your way”), but at this point I’m imagining that if Prince never forced the engineer to delete the track it obviously didn’t go deep enough.
‘Jill Jones’ (1987) 13th October 1986
Another class cut from the Jill Jones debut record that Prince spent four years intermittently recording since starting in 1982, before evidently losing interest in by the time it was released in 1987.
‘Sign “☮” the Times’ (1987)- 28th November 1986
One month before His marriage to Susannah was called off and He was apparently feeling so bad that he wouldn’t even allow recorded evidence be released to the world, Prince was making a song as gleefully positive as He’d ever produced. However, when you learn that it stems from Prince’s final recording session with Susannah, lines like “We gonna dance every dance/Like it’s gonna be the last time” do come with added poignancy.
And, to be honest, you do kind of need to search for poignancy in one o’ ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ least compelling songs. It’s well sequenced to follow the dour state of address of the album’s title track, plus the guitar playing is exquisite, and the strange turn the final part of the song takes mean it’s a long way above average. But simply being an incredibly sequenced party track means it’s always likely to be overshadowed by the astonishing reaches the rest of the album makes.
Those lyrics though?? “We gonna love all our enemies/Till the gorilla falls off the wall”? What? “Aah, pop goes the music/When the big white rabbit begin to talk”? What?? “And the color green will make your best friend leave ya/It will make ’em do the walk/But that’s cool/’Cause one day, everyday will be a yellow day”? WHAT??? For a song so boorishly preachy regarding drug use, Prince sure seems to be tripping.
34 Can’t Stop This Feeling I Got
unreleased version – 17th June 1986
I have to say, we’re three years away from 1990’s ‘Graffiti Bridge’, and I’m scared. I’ve not listened to the album in years (I respect the sanctity of this journey, you know), but I remember it being the first Prince album that I heard that I thought was a stone cold turkey. What’s more, so much of the album has already turned up on this journey: Tick Tick Bang dates back to the ‘Controversy‘ era; New Power Generation was recorded in the ‘1999‘ sessions as Bold Generation; we saw The Question of U turn up last year; and this isn’t the last we’ll hear from the album on this list.
What are we about to run into here? Will this be the result of Prince’s issues with Warner getting to the point where He’s already refusing to let His best new music be released though their label? Are we about to experience Prince getting writer’s block??
One saving grace is that the versions of these older songs that appear on ‘Graffiti Bridge’ are almost always significantly less interesting, so that we at least know that Prince was only… erm… ruining His own songs on purpose…? Did He actually think they were better…?
Has anyone ever noticed that Prince can be really confusing sometimes?
Oh, and not including New Power Generation, that song slaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaps.
33 In a Large Room With No Lights
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020) – 7th May 1986
Everytime U wake up there’s a little motherfucker
Talkin’ big stuff in your face (Are U happy?)
U only get the kind of people that open their mouth just 2 swap feet
Welcome 2 the rat race
Initially planned for inclusion on ‘Dream Factory’, and recorded with the Revolution, including both Melvoin sisters, so obviously that’s getting shelved by the end of the year. The lyrics are attempted social commentary in the vein of the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ title track, though somehow far more nihilistic, and occasionally just ‘Around the World in a Day’ level bonkers (“A picture of a woman with a drink in her hand/Standing by a child with no eyes/Watching her reaction based upon revenge/Babies blown 2 kingdom come”).
It’s a gorgeous, jazz infused lament, that’s only slightly spoiled by a needlessly exaggerated “BAH-DE-LA-BABA-BABA-DADA!!” intro and occasional interlude, like every 90 seconds or so it decides it wants to be a Bond theme.
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020)– 16th November 1986
Not included in any known configuration of ‘Dream Factory’ or ‘Crystal Ball‘, and not included in the final ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ album. Cosmic Day was recorded a few days before Play in the Sunshine, and princevault.com suggests that Prince just thought “Nah, I like that happy song better”. Cosmic Day is true Prince Vaulter: never played live, never offered to anyone else, never once considered for release, it really is an example of His musical genius that He potentially never even thought about after November 1986.
31 La, La, La, He, He, Hee (Highly Explosive)
‘Sign “☮” the Times‘ single b-side; Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020) – ??th January 1987
The singer born Sheena Orr in Bellshill, Lanarkshire, Scotland, first found fame after being featured on the BBC series ‘The Big Time‘ in 1980, meaning that Esther Rantzen will have always played a small part in Prince history. In late 1983, Prince saw Sheena Easton perform on The Tonight Show “and Prince said ‘Ya, I gotta write something for that girl.’ And so he sent over Sugar Walls, and it was one of those things where it was like, ‘Here it is. If you want to do it, here’s my number'”. That famous ode to the vagina began a musical relationship that lasted longer and bore more fruit than a lot of the artists that were created by Prince
La, La, La, He, He, Hee might not be the most famous of their collaborations (stay tuned, folks), but it might be the most contested. The liner notes to the (fucking essential, I can’t stress that enough) ‘The Hits/The B-Sides’ 1993 compilation say that the song “resulted from Prince being asked [by Easton] to prove he could indeed get a full song out of those simple syllables”, and suggests that was the reason Prince was kind enough to give Easton a co-writing credit. However, Easton herself says she basically wrote all of the lyrics:
“La La La, He He He He, that was something I was writing, just a stupid little thing. See, I have six cats. It was about a cat up in a tree teasing a dog. I was actually being sarcastic. He said, ‘Ya, that could be a song,’ and I was like ‘Oh ya, like what do you want me to sing? La La La, He He He—I love you, you love me? That’s how talented I am?’ He said, ‘Actually, that’d be kind of cute! Go ahead and write it.’ I don’t really write any more as I’m out of the game now, but back then, that was my thing. Then, all my songs were little stories. I liked storytelling songs. He used to think they were amusing. I don’t think other people did but he used to think they were.
Easton to Windy City Times 2012/08/08
As always with these kind of contested histories, you always need to consider that they could both be lying.
But whoever was responsible for the lyrics, the song is a brilliant piece of psychedelic nonsense, perhaps the only Prince song to feature rhythmic dog barks. I’ve listed the longer version of the song that was featured as the b-side to the If I Was Your Girlfriend 12″, because as we know more is more and longer is always better.
Crystal Ball (1998); Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020)– 12th January 1987
Ooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooh!!

Despite the liner notes of the 1998 ‘Crystal Ball’ album* declaring that the beautiful, full sounding and orchestrally rich Crucial was initially intended for the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ album, that is literally the only time in history that has been stated as a fact. It’s not clear who wrote the liner notes of the 1998 compilation of previously bootlegged tracks, and it’s very possible that they’re right and everyone else is wrong. It’s possible that Prince Himself wrote the liner notes, and wanted to put something to bed that had irritated Him for more than a decade. Maybe Prince wanted to muddy the accepted truth about the song because He hated people pontificating about his unreleased projects. Maybe some poor intern at NPG Records had to write liner notes for each song before their 5pm deadline, looked at when Crucial was recorded and thought “So, probably for ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’? And replaced by… I wanna say… Adore…?”
(*which for the end of time would force people to make clear had no relation to the triple album that was planned to follow ‘Parade’, but was sure to have its own tortuous production that we will get to in approximately eleven years)
Outside of that, nobody else suggests the song was planned for inclusion on ‘Dream Factory’, ‘Crystal Ball’ (the actual one) or ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’. Respected Prince historial ‘Shagger’ Per Nilsen – who generally knows a lot about this sort of stuff – suggests that it was written for inclusion on ‘The Dawn’ soundtrack, and considering Prince recorded The Cocoa Boys the next day (which is surely from the movie… isn’t it…?), Shagger Per might be onto something. Confusingly, once work on ‘The Dawn’ was suspended, Crucial also appears in early drafts of the script to ‘Graffiti Bridge’.
Hmm? That dogshit 1990 movie? No, you idiot, a completely different ‘Graffiti Bridge’ movie that was planned in 1987. Haven’t you learned yet that things having the same name can sometimes be completely different. This version co-starred Madonna! Would this version have been good??
No. Not at all. It would have been dogshit. But that’s not the point.
29 Eggplant (Wendy Melvoin Vocal Version)
unreleased- 8th July 1986
Prince: Yo Lucy, give me some slack
You don’t even know the girl
Wendy: Oh yes I do
I know her kind exactly
She’s probably got a poodle named Fluffy
Prince: Yeah, I bet she got a real fluffy poodle
Wendy: Oh please…
Wendy: IQ of a ice cube
A serious wind tunnel
You know what I mean?
Prince: She’s beautiful
Wendy: She’s retarded – slow
But you won’t be satisfied ’til you marry a hag
Give birth to an eggplant
Oh, what a double-drag
The Prince vocal of Eggplant made the ‘Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition’ in 2020, but the very hilarious Wendy Melvoin duet (which Prince was obviously keen to re-record after the Revolution split a few months later) remains unreleased. Honestly, you call a woman “retarded” one time, and the tofu eating wokerati will silence you immediately.
b-side of Jill Jones’s single ‘Mia Bocca‘ (1987) – ??th January 1987
Seriously, Jill Jones was popping out songs this good even on her b-sides?/
The A-side, Mia Bocca is also a banger and was also written by Prince but, unfortunately, nobody seems to know when it was recorded so I can’t place it on any of these lists. I’m also not sure I want to touch the lyric “I’ve only had one lover since I was twelve years old” either.
77 Bleeker St is fabulous though, a proper 80’s belter that Tina Turner would have literally stamped on babies’ heads for the chance to record. Named after Bleecker Street in New York but, of course, misspelled.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 7th November 1986
“I don’t go to awards shows anymore. I’m not saying I’m better than anybody else. But you’ll be sitting there at the Grammys, and U2 will beat you. And you say to yourself, ‘Wait a minute. I can play that kind of music, too. I played La Crosse growing up, I know how to do that, you dig? But you will not do Housequake”.
I’ve always made a similar connection: whenever I hear Bono sing I think “Shut up already, damn”.
I don’t love Housequake as much as many Prince fans would demand I should – perhaps linked to me being an awkward white boy born in Tameside, Greater Manchester – but I can recognise that nobody could do it other than Prince.
In a way, even Prince Himself couldn’t release Housequake, or so He planned. That opening “Shut up already!” has extra meaning when you consider this was recorded the day after Prince had disbanded the Revolution. Everyone else really was shut up now. And Prince thought, what if I shut myself up…?
Prince had played with sped up vocal effects before, most notably on Erotic City, but what if He did a whole album with that effect, claim it was a completely different, androgynous singer and not mention the Prince connection at all!? Prince was inspired by the tale of Herculine Barbin, a 19th century French intersex/’hermaphrodite’ who would often refer to themselves as ‘Camille’, and this project had a name. The album’s eight tracks were recorded in the couple of months after the Revolution disbanded (including a rejig of the slightly older songs Feel U Up and Strange Relationship) and represent an astonishingly fruitful patch of creativity: there are four more songs from the ‘Camille’ eight track album to come, including both of the top two. The album was given a catalogue number by Warners – (9)25543 – and scheduled for a January 1987 release. It was cancelled for unknown reasons, with seven of the tracks being moved to the ‘Crystal Ball’ album, before eventually only three made ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’. Maybe it was cancelled because Warner Brothers were understandably reticent to have one of their most bankable names release a secret album under a different pseudonym, but the fact they went as far as to issue it with a catalogue number suggests that they were at least halfway accepting of the fact. Maybe that was back before they heard the tracks they assumed would be some Madhouse-level experimental commercial suicide, and not some of the greatest songs imaginable.
Or perhaps Prince just got a little nervous. I can’t think of any mainstream artist to this day who has made such a bold statement of gender fluidity and queer identity, especially not one assigned male at birth. We have artists who have transitioned, sure, but the most famous of these are probably Against Me’s Laura Jane Grace and Anthony/Anohni, who though popular within their communities are a long way from being mainstream, and whose transition was made public almost 30 years after ‘Camille’ was slated to be released. And we are just about entering an era where we allow openly transgender artists to be famous, with Kim Petra becoming the first to get a UK/US #1 single and to win a Grammy award in 2022. In general though, when a cishet artist as mainstream as Harry Styles even wears a dress it’s treated like Caravaggio unveiling Judith Beheading Holofernes in 1599. And this is 1987 we’re talking about. Glam metallers would wear make-up and feminine dress in order to shock (as they, more often than not, sexualy assaulted a large percentage of their fans backstage), but that was just rock music catching up to something Prince Himself had been doing since 1980’s ‘Dirty Mind’. And artists like David Bowie, Freddie Mercury and Marc Almond had always been a little bit fruity in their presentation, but that was always about challenging the conceptions of how a man should present himself. Even if, as most of the listeners would swear to you at the time, they were all straight as an arrow. Which, again, is all stuff Prince had been doing for years. And we can’t ignore the openly and exuberantly queer artists like Frankie Goes to Hollywood and future escort torturer and genocide supporter Boy George, but at the same time recognise how brave being so open was while accepting that celebrating homosexuality is different than completely subverting your own perceived gender.
Or maybe Prince just couldn’t possibly sanction releasing an album with only eight songs. Having said that, His planned follow up album to ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’, ‘The Black Album‘, also only has eight songs, so Him releasing that would prove that theory wrong.
Along with the three tracks that made ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’, the tracks that would have been on ‘Camille’ were eventually all officially released as b-sides, on random movie soundtrack albums, and finally with the 2020 ‘Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition’ completing the set. Weirdly, Jack White’s Third Man Records announced in 2022 that they’d bought the rights to release the album of songs that had already been released, though there’s been no word of that since, possibly as the company realised they’d paid thousands of dollars for the privilege of making a mixtape (“Prince’s people agreed, almost too easy”, yeah no shit). The quality of the music on ‘Camille’ is incredible, and at least the wider world is now able to fully appreciate that, but the story of the ‘Camille’ album is of an artist being so incredibly bold yet a truly historical pop culture moment so tantalisingly missed.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 19th July 1986
In 1983, while casting for the lead in the ‘Purple Rain’ movie, Prince met with aspiring actress Carole Davis:
“He was interviewing me not only for my singing and my acting. He wanted to hear me sing live and he realised that we could gel musically. That’s when I realised he was auditioning for a girlfriend as he was asking me very personal questions. Today, I would probably call up the Screen Actors Guild if I had that kind of meeting now. He got too close to me and in my physical space.
He became very angry and sullen and pouted like a four-year-old child when I told him I didn’t believe in Jesus. I was there for about two nights. There were no agents or managers there. That was totally inappropriate. There was this guy who was his bodyguard [Big Chick Huntsberry] who brought me to the studio. He [Prince] was really angry with me right before I left that morning. I opened the door to one of the bathrooms and he was standing there in his heels with his curling iron on. I knew that was a sight I should never have seen. Half of his hair was curled and the other half was a mess.”
Carole to John McKie in ‘Prince: A Sign o’ the Times‘
Despite those imperfect first impressions. Prince and Carole remained friends (“I always found Him to be amusing from a sociological viewpoint“), as she gained more prominence as an actor and also exhibiting a musical talent that saw her signed to Warner Brothers records. Y’know, the proper record company, not something that Prince had just set up on a whim. While Carole was working on the songs that would eventually feature on her 1989 debut ‘Heart of Gold‘, she played Prince a song that she was particularly pleased with, and the song stuck with Him. So much so that…
“I got a call years later from some lawyer just before it was released saying ‘We wanna buy the song from you outright for $25,000’. I immediately said no. The lawyer said, ‘You might wanna reconsider. If you’re not going to sell the song, it’s not going on the album’.
The gentlemen’s agreement when you write a song is that 50/50 is fair. He [Prince] didn’t want my name on the album. He didn’t make himself available even to discuss it. He made his team unavailable to my team. I remain angry about that to this day.”
Carole to John McKie in ‘Prince: A Sign o’ the Times‘
That song was Slow Love, which Carole didn’t sell, which meant she was able to finally release her own (original) version on her debut album, two years after Prince had fought so hard to hide her contribution from ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’. In fact, ‘contribution‘ is a far too delicate term – when listening to Carole Davis’s original it’s clear that what Prince released on His album is absolutely a cover version that He wanted to pass of as His own creation. A very good cover version, don’t get me wrong, almost definitely superior (though Carole’s version is still brilliant), but absolutely someone else’s song that Prince tried to steal. I can’t think of any previous instance of Prince doing something similar, and His reasons for turning down the American Live Aid was Him not wanting to sing lyrics written by someone else. Him originally giving Matarati the song Kiss before taking it back once they showed Him a far better song structure is similarly cheeky, but at the end of the day that was still His song. When we speak more on the album at the end of year, we’ll discuss more 1986/7 cracks that started to show in Prince previously perfect artistry.
For Carole Davis though, it was a long legal battle to get recognised as even the co-writer. Then, when Prince set up His own record label, she once again had to fight to remind Him of the credit, and once again with the estate after He died.
“He tried to screw me out of my own songwriting. For years and years, I had to struggle to get paid for that song. I couldn’t sue because I thought he would end up owning my house. He was so powerful.
He paid me for quite a few years and then he got a new publishing company and for a while I tried to get my money and I couldn’t. He never returned my call and I saw one printing of the record where my name wasn’t on it.
1 knew he really loved that song. Why would someone like Prince be desperate for my song? He’s a musical genius. I don’t come close to him in that area. After he died, I went after the estate and I’m beginning to get cheques…
It’s a very complex relationship. I might be one of the few women who have turned him down. We were mutually fascinated with each other. I remember having great laughs with him. I remember him, warts and all. He was very silly and giggly – very childlike and pathetically insecure as a man. I think it was linked to his height. He wanted to be all powerful and macho. It didn’t work for me.“
Carole to John McKie in ‘Prince: A Sign o’ the Times‘
The Black Album (1994) – ??th January 1987
By the time the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ came out, Prince already had the entirety of the follow-up album finished, and was planning to release it at the end of 1987. It would be unlike anything He’d ever done before. Prince by this point was worrying that He was losing connection with His black audience, that there was the belief in some circles that He’d neglected His black fans the more commercially successful He’d gotten. He would remark to others how whenever He’d go to clubs they would never be playing His music. Prince got the impression that the black audience believed he’d “Lost the funk”. OK, thought Prince, how about I make the funkiest album that anyone has ever heard? How about I make the motherfucking FUNK BIBLE!? No, actually, that working title is far too commercially viable: how about I call it ‘The Black Album‘?? It won’t be credited to anyone, the sleeve will just be black with no words or symbols, and nobody will know it’s me!!
If you’re wondering about chronology, this would be three years after ‘This Is Spinal Tap’ had parodied that exact line of thought.
However, the thoughts Warner Brothers A&R executive Lenny Waronker were slightly more mixed:
“‘I want to put this thing out and call it ‘The Black Album’, and nobody will know it’s me’. He’s saying this and I’m thinking, No, no, no, not in the middle of this record. ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’, it just started to breathe, it’s got months. If you put something out, there’s no way it’s going to be under the radar? If you put something out, there’s no way it’s going to be under the radar?“
But Prince in the mid 80’s gets what Prince in the mid 80’s wants, and this ferocious and murky malevolent funk of ‘The Black Album’ – that Prince would test out at clubs as soon as the songs were pressed and that a lot of people assumed was all recorded just as a present for Sheila E’s birthday party – would be Prince’s next record.
Superfunkycalifragysexy is perhaps the most intense song Prince ever recorded, standing out as being dark, twisted and mean-spirited on album that prides itself on being dark, twisted and mean-spirited. The lyrics concern some sort of ruthless orgy, which you’re not sure if Prince intentionally makes sound this disturbing. It all sounds fuelled by the kind of crazy drugs that you can only get your hands on once you make your first million, but we are assured that the only enhancement the guests need are a “bucket filled with squirreled meat”. Squirrel meat is a recurring motif on ‘The Black Album’. I’m sure this will sell as many copies as ‘Purple Rain‘.
The Black Album (1994)- 15th December 1987
“I was out at this club called Nell’s on 14th Street in New York, dancing with my friend and all of a sudden there was this little-er person that came and started dancing with me, and I was like, ‘Oh, that’s Prince. So cool.’
“And then cut to not that long after and someone was like, ‘Do you know Prince wrote a song about you?’ And it’s on the ‘Black Album’, which I still have, and it had a song on it called Cindy C. And now I know what was going through his mind as we were dancing”
And what was going through His mind was, apparently, that Cindy Crawford’s “furry melting thing awaits me”.
Though not as astonishingly outlandish as Superfunkycalifragysexy, Cindy C was another bass rattlingly slice of low register funk recorded for ‘The Black Album’. It’s one of the upcoming record’s stronger cuts… but also hints at some of the weaknesses of that soon to be legendary record. While ‘The Black Album’ certainly was markedly different than anything Prince had commercially released before, that record’s growing infamy over the next few years would also obscure the fact that it was also probably Prince’s weakest album by that point. It’s intensely exciting at points, obviously, and as a record intently designed to make you throw shapes it ensures that shapes will indeed be thrown, but there simply isn’t enough variety over its 45 minutes to not make it sound a little one note at times. It also features dancer Cat Glover doing a rap. Prince had invited her to the studio while the album was being recorded, and asked that she say something in the mic to test it. Cat decided to do the rap from J.M. Silk’s 1985 track Music Is The Key , not realising that Prince was recording and would put it on a track, with Prince not knowing the song and assuming it was all just Cat spitting bars from the dome (“With me not knowing about the music industry and copyright“). Yeah, we’ll get to how well Prince incorporated hip-hop into His sound, but let’s just say that Cat’s spirited effort on Cindy C when she didn’t know she was being recorded is about as good as it got. And considering the themes, ideas and genres imbued over Prince’s previous five… six… seven albums, ‘a funky album that black people will like’ can’t help but feel a little superficial. If Prince really did manage to sneak it out with nobody ever realising where it came on, it would have been an absolutely legendary record to stumble across from a complete unknown. As a Prince album though, it’s… subpar.
Was it also Prince’s weakest album by 1994? Well, that’s a very different question, and I’m struggling to understand at this point in 1987 why you’re asking…
unreleased version – ??th January 1987
This would not appear on ‘The Funk Bible’ (despite the awesome bass guitar playing).It would, however, be recorded and released by Mavis Staples on her fourth album and first on Paisley Park Records ‘Time Waits for No One‘ in 1989. It’s an absolutely gorgeous, low effort ballad, which might not make you feel all supercalifragifunky-whatever, but is just an exquisite piece of songwriting.
unreleased version – 18th June 1986
All together now: “LATER RELEASED ON ‘GRAFFITI BRIDGE’ IN 1990!!!!!”
That ‘Graffiti Bridge’ version would be quite different and feature George Clinton though. In fact, to include it on this countdown I’ve had to convince myself over long and vicious internal debates that this 1987 track counts as a new song, and is significantly different than We Can Fuck, recorded way back before even ‘Purple Rain‘ was released. It’s not even entirely clear when the tofu eating wokerati convinced Prince to censor the title of the track between its first appearance and eventual official release. But the YouTube account ‘Gia FUNK’ calls it ‘We Can Funk (1986 version)’ so I think we can consider that case closed. Then, because we all weren’t confused enough, suddenly in 2011, at that time New Power Generation vocalist and guitarist Andy Allo announced on her Facebook page “CHECK OUT WHAT EYE FOUND IN PRINCE’S VAULT (Demo recorded in Sacramento on 8/31/11 using ProTools 9 & a Sterling Audio ST69 Mic)”, before another significantly different version of the song called Oui Can Luv was soon uploaded online.
What makes the 1986 version significant is how it strips the previous version’s electropop elements for dirty, dirty, dirty down low bass, with strings you imagine wobbling like a SONAR picking up major disturbances down deep, and how that the version would not just fit beautifully onto ‘The Black Album’ but (whispers) be easily one of the best songs.
Sheena Easton: ‘The Lover In Me’ (1988),- 10th January 1987
Get in a taxi, subway train
Don’t make me cry these tears in vain, baby
A hundred nights without you is murder baby
A 101 just won’t do, no
Remember when I said before that we hadn’t yet got to Prince and Sheena Easton’s most famous collaboration??
Well, this isn’t it either. Obviously, come on, you’ve probably never heard of this song. But what a song, ammi right, lads?? And look at that single cover! I owe you an apology, Ms Easton, I wasn’t familiar with you being a stone cold cutie-patootie.
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020) – 4th November 1986
The opening track of ‘lost’ game changing album ‘Camille’, and an explicit introduction to the project while also perhaps being an implicit statement of its goals? Is Prince’s the one being ‘reborn’ into this new genderfluid intersex being (who is an outstandingly talented songwriter)? And, considering the anonymity that the ‘Camille’ album was planned to be released under, was it a knowing joke to there was no ‘flesh’/body for the listener to associate it with? Was the rebirth Prince moving away from His poppier recent work into more pure funk? Is it an attempted follow-on to the much discussed January 1986 jam sessions referred to as ‘The Flesh‘, parts of which were intended to reappear on the later shelved ‘The Flesh’ album? IE: was it the sequel to an unreleased jam session that formed the basis for an album that never came out, in the most ‘Prince’ move imaginable? Or is the ‘rebirth of the flesh’ actually just… sigh – “The rebirth of the flesh is all over you” – all about spunk?
I guess now we’ll never know, but it’s once again a song that would fit beautifully onto ‘The Black Album’ (and – whispers – be easily one of the best songs.), lending more credence to Susannah Melvoin stating how closely she believed the two to be linked (“I think it was cathartic for Him“), especially considering He recorded the first song for ‘The Black Album’ (Superfunkycalifragysexy) the day after recording the first song for ‘Camille’ (spoilers!). And both were done, notably, so soon after He’d disbanded the Revolution.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 23rd December 1986
Remember when I said before that we hadn’t yet got to Prince and Sheena Easton’s most famous collaboration??
Yeah, so this was probably it.
Relatively low? Perhaps. But you have to understand how it is wall to wall bangers from this point on. And while this infectious stadium glam rock classic is obviously brilliant, as a gloriously dumb party track, it obviously lacks the depths and the finesse of some of Prince’s best work of this 12 month period. Oh, a lot of the tracks still to come and still fucking dumb, don’t get me wrong, just in a slightly more intellectually satisfying way.
The reference to “Color you peach and black” is significant though, as that was Prince’s chosen colour scheme for the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ era. Prince is most often tied to the colour purple, but that’s simply another consequence of so many people tying Prince to the ‘Purple Rain’ period (again, understandable, no other period’s success comes close).But Prince was as big a chameleon as any musical artist ever, and liked to denote album ‘eras’ with different colour schemes. After ‘Purple Rain’ Prince went kaleidoscopic with ‘Around the World in a Day‘ and was most often seen during the period wearing the sky blue suit that he had on in the Raspberry (another colour) Beret video. ‘Parade‘ was all sheer blacks and whites to emphasise the monochrome, and now ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ would be peach and black. Future album rollouts would be coloured blue and fuchsia (‘Lovesexy’); yellow and gold (‘Diamonds and Pearls’); gothic grey (‘Come’); orange (‘Emancipation’) electric blue (‘Rave In2 the Joy Fantastic’); ugh, browns (‘The Chocolate Experience’); orange and black (‘3121’); even up to black and white of His posthumous album ‘Welcome 2 America’. Oh, and there’s ‘The Black Album’ too, I guess. And ‘The Gold Experience’. Is crystal a colour…? It would change a lot, is what I’m saying, which is why Paisley Park was designed to be white so any current colour scheme could be projected onto it.
And then Prince’s sister Tyka revealed to the Evening Standard in 2017 that her brother’s favourite colour was fucking orange, which I just don’t think a lot have people have come to terms with yet.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 24th November 1986
Relatively low? Perhaps. But you have to understand how it is wall to wall bangers from this point on. And though Prince is often (if not universally) lauded as the greatest performer of sex jams ever, it’s just a style that has never really gelled with me. If you dare to insinuate that’s because I’m an unfuckable and sexless incel, I shall simply remind you that your Mum wasn’t complaining about that last night, mate.
But Adore is Prince’s greatest ever sex jam, several furlongs ahead of Do Me Baby in 2nd place. It’s a gorgeously constructed song, almost gospel like in its spirituality.
The Black Album (1994) – ??th December 1985
Le grind
All the boys, grab a girl, get down on the floor, ooh
This funky beat’s gonna show you
Gonna show you what your hips are made for
Uh, nouveau grind, come on
(People) people it’s much too late
It’s much too late to be shy
London, what does Big Ben say?
OK, motherfuckers, none of you are ready for this unbridled funk! TO THE DANCE FLOOR! Who’s an unfuckable and sexless incel now, huh?
Hey, pretty mama, with the long hair (grind)
Is that your boyfriend? (Grind)
Ha, I don’t care (grind)
‘Cause’ I can do, said I can do tricks he can never do (grind)
When I get naked, we’ll see the real you
No other song lives up more to the album’s ‘Funk Bible’ conceit, and opens the album with “So you found me/Good, I’m glad/This is Prince, the cool of cools” statement that you have no choice to agree with. It’s a delirious, impossibly funky, and the only reason it’s so relatively low is that it doesn’t go on for 50 minutes. Come on, Prince, don’t pretend you haven’t made 50 minute songs before.
LONDON! WHAT DOES BIG BEN SAY?!?!
‘Bright Lights, Big City’ soundtrack album (1988)
Ohmyfuckinggod, joy joy joy! And it turns out – “Technicolor children in Piccadilly Square/Whisper words, erotica, when you kiss me there” – that was what Big Ben was saying.
A sister song to Raspberry Beret, that manages to be both centred around the whimsical joys associated with love while also going fucking hard. The synth effects are beguiling, the composition is as good as almost anything Prince was recording at the time, and it’s more proof of the near inhuman quality of the music that was recorded for the ‘Camille’ album. Oddly, while the surrounding album never materialised, Prince ended up releasing Goodlove in 1988, not as a b-side but on the soundtrack to the Michael J Fox movie ‘Big Lights Big City’, the first time that Prince had allowed a film to feature a previously unreleased song. You can only assume that Prince felt the James Bridges directed film really embodied the joyous affections so giddily expressed in the song.

Ah. OK. So it seems that Prince was just doing something completely random for no discernible reason? Cool. One of the most written about and obsessed over artists in recent history can still all too frequently just do shit that absolutely nobody can explain.
‘Graffiti Bridge’ (1990) – 27th July 1986
Talking to no one in particular, they say “the baddest I am tonight”
Four letter words are seldom heard with such dignity and bite
All the poets and the part time singers always hang inside
Live music from a band plays a song called Soul Psychodelicide
The song’s a year long and had been playing for months
When he walked into the place
No one seemed to care, an introverted this-is-it look on most of their faces
Up on the mic repeating two words, over and over again
Was this woman he had never noticed before he lost himself in the
Articulated manner in which she said them
These two words, a little bit behind the beat
I mean just enough to turn you on
For everytime she said the words another one of his doubts were gone
You know the drill by now:
I had initially considered the available and unreleased ‘1986 version’ for this list, but the indispensable princevault.com doesn’t list any further mixing or addition to the song after July 1986. Even the applause intro wasn’t added for the ‘Graffiti Bridge’ album, as it was originally added as a segue from The Ball on the (OG) ‘Crystal Ball’ album. In 1990, it would segue from We Can Funk, which we saw at #22. Seriously, Prince, did you do any work on that fucking album??
What an absolute stonker of a song though, a swaggering, understated yet cinematically epic story song that features one of Prince’s greatest guitar solos. It’s often talked about being one of Prince’s greatest deep cuts, hidden gems, or underappreciated classics. Oh, by the way, pretty much anything good Prince released after 1987 is generally thought of being a deep cut/hidden gem/underappreciated classic.
unreleased – 5th November 1986
OK, we are actually in deep cut territory here, an unreleased marvel that nobody heard even after it was given to Nona Hendryx and her (vastly inferior) version became the third single off her 1987 album ‘Female Trouble’,
God, that Prince version though. That collapsing synth line – like a keyboardist being pushed down the stairs but somehow still managing to keep to some sort of beat – that the song hangs on is one of the most infectious musical riffs of the period, and this majestic track was probably given away simply because Prince couldn’t see how it would fit on ‘The Black Album’. Prince, man, come on! Who the fuck is Nona Hendryx???
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020)– 22nd November 1986
Over on the east side across the river
There was a band called The Cocoa Boys
The leader was a brother named Frankie, huh
He was the ladies pride and joy
Yes he was
Now Frankie had a brother named Joe
And they shared the high-part harmonies
Joe played the bass, Frankie played guitar
And people, I mean they was too funky
And every Sunday night up on the main strip
There always was a battle
(A musical battle of the bands)
And if you had the courage
If you had the style, if you had a different trip
You would have an extra hundred dollars in your hands
(Hundred bills, hundred dollars)
The brooding and stately The Cocoa Boys (occasionally referred to as just Coco Boys) is probably the nearest thing we have to any documented evidence of the aborted movie ‘The Dawn’. The story of competing bands apparently bore some resemblance to the later movie of ‘Graffiti Bridge’, but then it’s also very similar to the plot of ‘Purple Rain’, so it’s very possible that it’s a completely different movie and the idea of creating a band to compete against Himself was a subject that Prince kept going back to. The Cocoa Boys is something of an elevator pitch for the movie, which you’d imagine playing over the opening credits as it introduces the main antagonists of Joey and Frankie Cocoa. It also attempts to introduce not one (“Detroit Crawl”), not two (“Wooden Leg”), but three (“Kangaroo”) new dance moves, which is just insane. Prince, mate, take it from me in 2026, there hasn’t been one dance move properly introduced into wider popular consciousness since ‘The Griddy‘, and that was almost a decade ago! You’re obviously a very talented fellow, but you’ve got to know your limits.
12 I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 16th July 1986
Eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeesh, we’re possibly being loose with timeframes here. I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man actually dates back to nineteen seventy freaking nine, and was first recorded in the sessions for the ‘Prince’ album as a new wave bop far more genre expansive than anything that made the record. It then lay untouched for more than seven years before being resurrected into a powerpop magnum opus for the ‘Dream Factory’ album. No, screw that, for the ‘Crystal Ball’ album. Sigh, fine, for the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ album. I have, in my infinite (infinite, infinite, infinite) wisdom, decreed that the epic scope and psychedelic breakdown of the 1986 version marks it out as a different enough song to feature on this list. Also: It’s my list, so fuck all y’all.
Of course, one major difference between ‘Dream Factory’ and ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ is that the Revolution had been disbanded before the latter was recorded, so Prince obviously had to re-record every song that featured the band with Him instead playing all the instruments. It could have been because Prince genuinely believed that His versions sounded better and suited the album more – and they do sound really fucking good – or it could have just been Him being incredibly petty. Both would be facets of Prince’s personality with plenty of previous and future evidence to back up – both His incredibly single minded dedication to musical perfection and His jealous guarding of His own music that could lead to vindictive spite – and a small part of Prince’s enduring appeal is that His careerlong secrecy means we’re still debating these facets a decade after His death.
The Black Album (1994) – 10th December 1986
I pay the rent in this raggedy motherfucker
And all you do is suck up food and heat
Say what, oh yeah?
For someone who can’t stand no T.V. dinners
You sure eat enough of them motherfuckers
Who bought you that diamond ring?
Yeah, right
Since when did you have a job?
You seeing that rich motherfucker again
What’s his name? Bob?
Bob, ain’t that a bitch?
What’s he do for a living?
Manage rock stars?
Who?
Prince, ain’t that a bitch?
That skinny motherfucker with the high voice?
Please, who do I look like baby?
Yesterday’s fool?
Don’t you know I will kill you now?
You’re fuckin’ right, I gotta gun
You think I don’t?
Then what’s this?
Oh, you quiet now, uh-uh
Little?
Yeah, right
It might be little but it’s loud
The weird, minimalist, funky*, hilarious undisputed highlight of ‘The Black Album’. A furious trap diss track decades before trap music was invented, with a beat so dank that you worry about your next week’s bowel movements after listening to it. It’s also a mockery of the toxic masculinity that Prince viewed to be endemic in the current fad of hip-hop, a failure to understand the genre that would play a part in Prince’s future musical descent.
(*obviously)
The titular Mr George – whom Prince dilates between speaking to as Bob’s own conscience (“Bitch!”) and just as a physical person shooting Bob with a gun – is said to be a composite of Prince’s manager Bob Cavallo and music critic Nelson George. Nelson was and is a famous music critic, who was an early and longtime cheerleader for Prince but may be being called out here for being slightly more lukewarm on his review of the ‘Purple Rain‘ tour (“Overall it was quality arena rock show, but one with obvious room for improvement. The tour is already sold out until January, so Prince has no financial incentive to add older hits or rethink his staging. Still, he has led us to expect him to reach for greatness, and this show, for all his appeal, simply doesn’t do it”). I often see Bob Cavallo described as Prince’s former manager, as if Bob George was some vicious parting shot. But, like, Bob Cavallo is Prince’s former manager now, but he didn’t stop managing Prince until 1989, so the song was written and recorded more than two years before then. It’s important to remember that much of ‘The Black Album’ was first recorded and played for Sheila E’s birthday party, and there’s a nonzero chance that Cavallo would be expected to actually be in the crowd. It’s a joke song, Prince isn’t really fantasising about shooting his current manager and/or a music critic. It’s funny. It’s also one of Prince’s most endearingly odd songs, and one you couldn’t imagine near enough any of His contempries recording.
Ain’t that a bitch?
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 20th April 1986
Cynthia wore the prettiest dress
With different color socks
Sometimes I wondered if the mates were in her lunchbox
Me and Lucy opened it when Cynthia wasn’t around
Lucy cried, I almost died, you know what we found?
As a child, Susannah Melvoin went to school at Highland Park High in Los Angeles. She was taught by Kathy Smith in a class with her friends Kevin and Lucy, along with one student who’d made such a big impression on her and that she’d still kept in touch with by the time she was going out with Prince, by the name on Cynthia Rose. Cynthia was autistic, and would say her favourite number was twenty, as that was the safe speed limit for the road outside the school, and it would keep her calm. When school started at quarter to eight, Susannah would ask Cynthia what she’d had for breakfast, and Cynthia would reply every time “Starfish and peepee”.
“That’s beautiful!”, thought Prince when Susannah told Him this story. “Erm, can I change one thing though…?”
And while Susannah slept, Prince wrote and recorded Starfish and Coffee, playing it for her the next morning and giving her a co-writer credit.
Starfish and Coffee might not be among Prince’s absolute best songs – if I ever make that list it might sneak into the lower reaches of the top 100 – but it is absolutely one of His most beloved on account of it just being one of His loveliest. A near nursery rhyme structure and complete open hearted affection makes it so easy to fall for. Prince was also an early and continued advocate for people with autism, playing an intimate gig at the Koko in London in support of Autism Rocks as late as 2015.
“Some superstars seem diminished in small venues, like a blockbuster viewed on an aeroplane seatback screen, but Prince is even more impressive close-up. Dressed in shimmery silver and strings of beads (imagine if Jimi Hendrix had played a galactic priest in an episode of Star Trek), he moves with playful, faultless grace. You could spend the whole two hours just watching his face as he mugs, gurns, smirks and winks, as if finding his own virtuosity hilarious. He has that rare confidence of someone who knows in his bones that he’s the best at what he does, a confidence that passes through arrogance and arrives at a state of sheer joy.”
Dorian Lynskey in The Grauniad 2015/03/02
Sorry, just wanted to share that quote from the Autism Rocks performance review because it made my heart so full.
I was going to mention how Prince’s performance of the song on the Muppets Show in 1996 was likely supposed to coincide with a rerecording and rerelease on the upcoming children’s album ‘Happy Tears’, which was announced alongside His wife’s pregnancy, but that’s a tale for another day. And we’re having a nice time here.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 8th August 1986
Da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da…
Prince accidentally recorded Himself absentmindedly vocalising the melody of Forever In My Life, and it fit so well with the song’s lackadaisical and calmly underplayed statement of undying devotion that it was kept in. One of ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ less talked about tracks yet widely beloved among true ball knowers, it’s a minimalist piece of magic that’s nonetheless a production masterclass. Again, no other artist in the world could make a song like this.
‘Crystal Ball’ (1998) – 7th August 1986
Tell me what the bass say!
OK, so we’ve mentioned the album ‘Crystal Ball’ many times, and how it is not to be confused with the 1998 album ‘Crystal Ball’, now we have the song Crystal Ball, which was obviously intended as the centrepiece of the album ‘Crystal Ball’, but never made it onto ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’. However, it did eventually end up on ‘Crystal Ball’ (1998), but that doesn’t mean that album becomes relevant. When I mention ‘Crystal Ball’ it’s referring to the abandoned album ‘Crystal Ball’, not the 1998 compilation ‘Crystal Ball’. I am also now talking about the song Crystal Ball.
And what. A fucking. Song. An epic, experimental symphony of a song, that manages to combine the free jazz expansiveness of side projects like Madhouse with Prince’s own pop sensibilities, crafting both into an extremely listenable and moving 10+ minutes that Prince always intended to put His own name to. The song features full and incredible orchestration, and is the song in this period that Prince worked the longest on. It’s a piece of avant garde expressionism with pop music sensibilities (you will be singing along to that chorus!) that sounds incredibly ambitious in 2026, and must have broken people’s brains in 1986.
And the Warner Brothers executives brains did indeed break. When they pleaded with Prince to edit the ‘Crystal Ball’ triple album down a little, surely this crazy prog rock suite that sounds like it was made by Afrofuturistic aliens in the year 2099 (and they are partying like it’s 2099) would be the first thing they’d insist He cut. Warners were still desperate for a record as huge as ‘Purple Rain’ was a couple of years previously, they’d allowed the slight experimentations of ‘Around the World in a Day’ and ‘Parade’, but this shit was not going to be the next Let’s Go Crazy!
So Prince’s most experimental and most groundbreaking piece of music, that He’d worked more on than almost every other song He’d ever done, was simply condemned to The Vault. The version that eventually appeared on the other ‘Crystal Ball’ album in 1998 is apparently the same version that was planned to go on the original ‘Crystal Ball’ in 1986, but multiple other versions have been unearthed to a further glimpse into an absolutely fascinating creative time period. There’s even (sacrilegiously) a three minute and a half minute edit. That’s the single, yeah, Prince??
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 7th August 1986
Hot thing, barely twenty one
Hot thing, looking for big fun
Relax, everyone, Prince was 28 when He recorded this. Also: Prince was twenty fucking eight when he recorded this??
Funnily enough, the one track on ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ that actually mentions the previously aborted project (“Hot thing, maybe you should give your folks a call/Hot thing, tell them you’re going to the Crystal Ball/Hot thing, tell them you’re coming home late/If you’re coming home at all”). Without the context of the surrounding album it sounds like a frivolous bit of nonsense similar to Play in the Sunshine‘s gorilla falling off the wall, but considering that this was likely the same Crystal Ball that Prince also spends ten minutes warning about, it may well at one point have been a far darker tale.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 13th July 1986
Don’t cry, He is coming
Don’t die without knowing the cross
Okaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay, let’s approach this lightly…
Prince was always religious. He was raised as a Seventh Day Adventist, who you might be able to categorise better than me if you’re up on your Christianity lore. He had previously had conversations with God onstage, and songs like The Ladder and even Purple Rain are definitely concerned with reaching out to higher beings, but in the 80s was hard to nail down religiously, and obviously believed in a God who was cool with the whole “Might be qualified for a one night stand” thing.
However, The Cross isn’t just a vaguely religious song, it’s not just spiritual or metaphysicaly minded – it’s an extremely direct take on the explicitly Christian story of Jesus Christ’s execution and the upcoming Second Coming. It’s stunning. It’s intense. It speaks to Prince’s personal and profound admiration of the (cough, alleged) sacrifice of Jesus Christ Superstar, and it’s powerful enough to make a believer out of the most deluded cynic. It was a song that Richey Edwards once said he wished he’d written.
Of course, religion would play a far more central part in both Prince’s life and His music. Specifically His conversion to the Jehovah’s Witness belief in the mid-90’s. Jehovah’s Witnesses believe that Jesus was actually crucified on a single stake called a ‘staurus‘. Because of this, Prince would instead later perform the song as The Christ. Yeah, we got some real bullshit coming up in the next few years.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 11th May 1986
An incredible piece of work. Bombastic, infectious, and overpowering. Yeah, obviously, it’s widely accepted that the “It”about which Prince admits that He would “think about it, baby, all the time, all right”, and that “feels so good it must be a crime, all right” is sex. But Prince sings with such pain and yearning that I’ve always found it so hard to accept is only concerned with electrified lust.
As a teenager, I would always imagine the song was about suicide and self-harm. That the ‘you’ the singer is so anxiously addressing is the blade that He could slice his arms with (“With you I swear, I’m a maniac, all right”), that what He so yearns for is the sweet release of death. He doesn’t sing “Fucking on your mind”, he simply exasperatedly swears “Fucking, on your mind”. One more cut on the lower arm, underneath where your shirt would reach, “‘Cause when we do it girl, it’s so divine, all right”.
Yeah, I was a pretty fucked up kid. But the fact I could make that analysis speaks to how incredibly deep this little song about fucking can be read into.
Sign O’ The Times Super Deluxe Edition (2020) – 19th July 1986
Train was always my Vault song.
I probably originally came across it as a Limewire download, or perhaps it was included in some torrent compilation, but it was the first unreleased Prince track that really showed me what exact level of quality these songs that He would abandon into The Vault were. People would talk, but I always assumed that The Vault would be full of poorly recorded demos and first take suggestions of things that could have been turned into big tracks with a bit of studio polish. But that skinny motherfucker with the high voice was dumping songs as perfect as this??
Built on a irresistible rhythm obviously mimicking the repeating chugs of a train’s engine, it’s a masterfully produced gospel concerning the singer accepting that they can’t tie their lover down and has to let them go. Recorded three months after Prince was threatening to build a Big Tall Wall around His lover to stop her escaping, so that’s emotional growth at least. This alltimer of a track was scheduled to appear on ‘Dream Factory’, but didn’t even make it to the next aborted album ‘Crystal Ball’, never mind all the way to ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’. It would be given to Mavis Staples in 1988, and her version is really, really, really good, but it sounds like it was recorded at least a couple of decades before the Prince version, and somehow sounds less produced and less well constructed. I’ve always assumed that The Train – one of the greatest latter day Outkast deep cuts – was heavily influenced by this lost track by an artist the group were big fans of.
It was finally released on the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times Super Deluxe Edition’ in 2020, so any power I had over the dreaded normies was diffused. Now it’s merely forced to be merely one of Princes greatest released songs.
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 16th July 1986
Oh yeah!
Prince and Susannah caught a plane to LA in mid 1986 and picked up a Minneapolis Star and Tribune to read on the flight. The Tribune was reporting on Minneapolis’s first major wave of street gang activity, and detailed local murders by local gangs such as the Vice Lords, the Latin Kings, and the Black Gangster Disciples. In June 1986 there was news of Hurricane Bonnie causing $42 million worth of damage in Texas and Louisiana. The July 13 1986 L.A. Times included the headlines ‘Star Wars Leads All Defense Costs‘ about president Ronald Reagan’s anti-missile program, and ‘New AIDS Findings to Alert a World at Risk‘ about a conference in Paris. Gangs called The Disciples; hurricanes ripping ceilings off churches; Star Wars fly; a big disease with a little name… Prince went into the studio to record the title track and lead single for His next album.
Well, it was actually to record the opening track of the second disk of ‘Dream Factory’, but let’s go with the flow here.
Musically, Sign ☮︎’ the Times is one of the boldest musical statements He would ever make. Little more than sparse and chilling arrangement Prince fashioned using His new toy of the state of the art Linn LM-1 drum machine. Alongside that spectral drum cadence, you have Prince giving one of His greatest vocal performances (the climaxing “Some say man ain’t happy truly until a man truly dies/Oh why, oh why/Siiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiign of the times” will floor you), you get the occasional fidgety guitar riff, a bass firing in when it sees fit, and that’s your lot. Yet Prince still decided to have this weird and intimate dark near tone poem be not only the opening and title track of His new album (eventually), but also the lead single. The single’s cover featured a person wearing a peach (obviously) dress and obscuring their face with a black (obviously) heart, a person many assumed to be Prince once again playing with His fluid gender expectations (actually dancer and Cindy C rapper Cat Glover, but you can definitely see where people were coming from).
Lyrically, the What’s Going On comparisons are extremely valid. It’s a similar state of the nation address by one of the leading black musical figures of the time, and it’s the title and opening track to the record that would widely be considered that artist’s masterpiece. While Gaye’s classic concerned a former soldier returning from serving in an unjust war to witness more suffering in the USA, Sign ☮︎’ the Times is more Prince just repeating things he’s heard about in recent news. And, if we’re being honest, sometimes sounds like a 29 year old Boomer who gets all of His news from whatever 1986’s version of Fox was. “In France, a skinny man died of a big disease with a little name” is an incredible opening line, but seems to echo the easily debunked conspiracy theory that (French Canadian) Gaëtan Duga was the Patient Zero perhaps intentionally behind the AIDS crisis. Why is it only worth our dismay when “Hurricane Annie ripped the ceiling off a church and killed everyone inside”? And “In September, my cousin tried reefer for the very first time/Now he’s doing horse – it’s June” is gateway drug, slippery slope, Reefer Madness panic that kids in 1980’s America would be used to hearing from their parents and schools. Prince, who had so recently been the absolute epitome of everything that was cool, was starting to sound a little bit… like a square…? What’s Going On seemed to capture the mood of a nation, if nor the Western world. Sign ☮︎’ the Times was more a declaration of Prince’s loosening grip on the zeitgeist.
1987 would also see the release of ‘Paid In Full’, ‘Bigger and Deffer‘, Public Enemy’s incredible ‘Yo! Bum Rush the Show’, the debut album from Ice T, and the debut release by NWA. The culture was already starting to roll its eyes at people complaining about “Being in a gang called The Disciples, high on crack and totin’ a machine gun”.
If I Was Your Girlfriend single b-side – 7th November 1986
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa-AH!!
Jesse Johnson was the original lead guitarist of The Time, and appeared with them in the film ‘Purple Rain’. I was going to say which Time albums he played on, but considering The Time’s music was all recorded by Prince with a little input from Morris Day, Johnson didn’t actually play on any of them. As a passionate musician who had previously played in a number of actual bands, this creatively stifling arrangement was obviously frustrating for Johnson, and he left The Time at the height of their career in 1984 to work as a solo artist, releasing his debut album ‘Jesse Johnson’s Revue‘ in 1985. His solo career went well enough, really breaking though with the January 1986 mini hit Crazay, featuring none other than Sly Stone and reaching #2 on the US Billboard Hot Black Singles Chart. Yes, that was the name of the chart, but no, we don’t have time to go into that right now. It was looking like the release of the second album, ‘Shockadelica’, was shaping up to be a pretty big hit .
The way Jesse tells it, it was soon after he announced the title of his second album that Prince reached out to his former ’employee’. His engineer Susan Rogers attempted to get Jesse to meet Prince for dinner. Jesse declined, so Rogers explained that Prince strongly believed that a record with a title as strong as ‘Shockadelica’ really needed a title track, and that Prince had written one that would be perfect. Though Jesse again politely declined, “The song comes over,” Johnson said. “In the middle of the night, it’s on my doorstep. I said, ‘I’m good, I don’t need this song, you keep that'”.
“He said, ‘Well, if you don’t put it out, I’m gonna put it out, and when they think of Shockadelica, they will think of me. I was a young motherfucker then, and still pretty fucking crazy, but my reaction was like, ‘Hey man, do what you gotta do.’ That’s all I could say. I had to just zoom, mellow, check out, back away from that shit, because I was a very young father.”
Jesse Johnson points to Prince’s release of the song as the final straw in their relationship, and would later accuse him of sabotaging his solo career. The ‘Shockadelica Affair’ would mean they wouldn’t talk again until Prince invited Jesse back for the 1990 ‘Purple Rain’ ‘sequel’ movie ‘Graffiti Bridge’.
I find it hard to feel the adequate amount of sympathy for Jesse Johnson though, because what do you fucking mean you turned this songs down??
Shockadelica is an absolute riot, up their with the most undeniable and irresistible demands to invade the dancefloor that God has ever seen fit to allow mere mortals to ingest. It’s a hundred times funkier than anything on the Funk Bible, ‘The Black Album’, but that statement sounds like casting unnecessary shade onto the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ follow up record: Shockadelica is a hundred times funkier than anything on pretty much any album ever. If anything on Beyoncé’s ‘Renaissance’ had any dance songs anyway near as forward thinking and resembling as much an attempt at alien communication as Shockadelica, I might not have been so cold on that album. And Prince gave Mrs fucking Knowles a thirty five year head start. If someone were to tell me that Shockadelica was their favourite ever Prince song (which the band Ween would say and lead to them including the semi cover L.M.L.Y.P on their debut album), I’d get it – perhaps no other song better represents the crazed, boundlessness, cheeky and a little dark creative fire that burned within Prince’s very being. Shockadelica is at once the stupidest and greatest song that’s ever been released, it’s true rock and roll energy and true funk majesty.
The lights go out, the smell of doom
Is creepin’ into your lonely room
The bed’s on fire, your fate is sealed
And you’re so tired and the reason is Camille
And while making it, Prince did enjoy the pitch shifting He’d employed on His voice… And He did like the name ‘Camille’… Hmmm, maybe there’s something He can do there… The song Shockadelica was the song that inspired the whole ‘Camille’ project, and Susannah Melvoin even considers the recording of the song as the real start of Prince’s post-Revolutiong period. That tracks, as I imagine putting a song as good as Shockadelica on tape has gotta convince you that you can do anything.
That Jesse Johnson’s story though, never quite holds together for me. Johnson makes out like he’s still resentful of how Prince torpedoed his solo career by quick releasing Shockadelica before his second solo album of the same name had even come out… but… the ‘Shockadelica’ album was released September 15 1986… According to the always trustworthy princevault.com, Prince didn’t even start recording Shockadelica the song until 16 September 1986. Clearly inspired by Johnson’s album title, but a bit too fucking late to be offering song suggestions, mate, the album’s on the shelves of Our Price as we speak. And yet He released this to fuck with your upcoming album? Prince barely ‘released’ it at all: it came out as a b-side… on May 7 1987. That same princevault.com article claims that the song “premiered on Minneapolis radio station KMOJ a couple of days after it was recorded (a few weeks before the release of Jesse Johnson’s album) giving the impression that Johnson stole the title from Prince”. But, no, how? How? How? How? It wasn’t even recorded until the day after the ‘Shockadelica’ album came out, how was it sent to the radio station KMOJ?? All the other references to the song being played on KMOJ link back to the princevault.com page (if they list sources at all), while the princevault.com page doesn’t even link to a source!!
I’m sure that Prince was a absolute bastard to work for; I’m sure that he’d often use his insane level of creativity to troll those around Him; I’m sure that Jesse Johnson has countless reasons to be fucked off with Prince; I’m sure that Prince told Jesse very soon after ‘Shockadelica’ had been released that He’d written a song with that same name, and I’m fairly confident Prince would have boasted that it’s better than anything on Jesse’s album. However, I feel like over the years legends and theories have been repeated and mistaken for truth and the myth has built over a song that was eventually only released as a B-side.
A b-side to… to… to this next song, actually:
Sign “☮” the Times (1987) – 2nd November 1986
Look at the bargains over here, ladies
No, not ‘Ur‘ Girlfriend, so loses points for that I guess.
We discussed the album’s opening track – the unfiltered and sparsely decorated slice of pure genius that was the ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ title track – at #3, and spoke about about what an insane choice for lead single that brutally cold piece of minimalist electronica was. But Prince was still Prince, this was still the opening trailer for a hotly anticipated new album by one of the biggest artists in the world, so it still got to number 3 on the US Billboard chart (and #1 on the Hot Black Singles Chart. It was the hottest black single that week). Prince was still at a point where he’d have to freak people out a fucking whole lot if he wasn’t going to have a hit.
Hold by beer, thought Prince, as he prepared the record’s second release.
If I was your girlfriend, would you remember
To tell me all the things you forgot when I was your man?
Hey hey, when I was your manIf I was your best friend, would you let me
Take care of you and do all the things that only a best friend can?
Oh, only best friends can
Obviously originally intended for the ‘Camille’ album. On that record it would have been an androgynous person imagining taking on traditional gender roles, and that role being neither stereotypically aggressively masculine nor submissively feminine, but rather a female trusted as a close friend by the female Camille is singing to, in the hope of their relationship being as close as best friends, closer than just merely lovers. As the centrepiece of the ‘Camille’ album (and it would be the centrepiece of any album it was on), it flips the album in an almost meta way. Where Prince would always point out that, while Camille was obviously a more feminine character, they are themselves actually without sex or gender. Yet here is Prince singing as an androgynous character but still as that androgynous character wishing they were female, calling further into question whatever other assumptions the listener has made about the entire project.
Then Prince just removed it from that project, stuck it on ‘Sign ☮︎’ the Times’ and released it as the record’s second single without any context.
Well, He actually stuck it on the second disk of ‘Crystal Ball’, but let’s go with the flow here.
It was Prince’s most emotionally vulnerable song by quite a distance. None of the wider gender fluidity of the ‘Camille’ project is present, and instead it sounds like a desperately unguarded Prince wishing dearly that He could possibly be as delicately intimate with His girlfriend as she is with those she trusts most. It’s not clear whether this a desperate attempt to rescue their relationship (“Would you run to me if somebody hurt you even if that somebody was me?”) or to get as close to the woman He loves as possible and to learn 100% of her being (“I want to be all of the things you are to me”). It’s an impassioned plea to be someone’s everything and appreciating every single facet of their life (Would you let me wash your hair?/Could I make you breakfast sometime?/Well then, could we just hang out/I mean, could we go to a movie and cry together?”). Yeah, there’s sex involved as well, because Prince is imagining being absolutely everything for His woman, and we’re not about to be so prudish we pretend not to appreciate how sex would be involved in that. But then it’s perhaps the most tender sex song ever released, a humble, almost apologetic admission that you could never be close enough to your partner to truly appreciate them as a fully three dimensional sexual being… but you’d like to try… It’s also a near unmatched celebration of the power and importance of female friendships, sung by an incredibly horny musical prodigy whose attitudes concerning women were not always on the level.The music underpinning this great curiosity is underplayed, subtle, initially difficult to even perceive, but as impressive a compositional achievement as anyone has ever done.
Of course, in 1987 everyone thought it was super gay and it bombed out at #67 on the US charts. How could he be someone’s girlfriend?? It doesn’t make sense!! And he wants to cry at the cinema?? What, like a big queer?? I’ve just managed to convince my friends at the office he’s no homo with all the fucking he does, but this?!?! And why does his voice sound like that??? I regret to inform you all that it wasn’t even ranked among the ten hottest black singles.
Of course, almost forty years later those of us with two brains and a heart know it’s one of the hottest black singles ever…




























